Both Hats vs. My Solo 401k Financial: Solo 401(k) Comparison
Last reviewed by a credentialed actuary on our team
Note: Independent comparison
Both Hats publishes this comparison on its own. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by My Solo 401k Financial. We use that company’s name only to identify it. Its details come from its public web pages on the dates shown, and prices and features can change. To report an error, email hello@bothhats401k.com and we will correct it.
How do Both Hats and My Solo 401k Financial compare?
Both Hats plans to offer, and My Solo 401k Financial already offers, a solo 401(k) plan document that permits voluntary after-tax contributions and in-plan Roth conversions, the two features the in-plan mega backdoor Roth needs. The main differences are price, how long each has been operating, where the plan’s money can be held, and how much of the yearly recordkeeping each provider handles.
Both Hats is not open for enrollment yet. Its column describes the service as announced, with public enrollment planned for fall 2027.
| Item | Both Hats Solo 401(k) | My Solo 401k Financial |
|---|---|---|
| Availability | Not yet available. Public enrollment planned for fall 2027; refundable reservations open after company formation and document licensing. | Available now. Says it has been in business since 2009.1 |
| First-year price | $349 setup, including the first 12 months | $650 setup, covering the first 12 months1 |
| Annual fee after year one | $99 per year | $125 per year, starting 12 months after setup1 |
| Reservation deposit | $100, refundable, credited toward setup | None stated on its pricing page1 |
| Who the fee covers | Not yet published | Says the setup fee covers “both spouses, both business partners, etc.”1 |
| Voluntary after-tax contributions | Yes, in the plan document | Yes; pricing page lists “voluntary after-tax contributions (a.k.a. mega backdoor)”1 |
| In-plan Roth conversion | Yes | Yes; says the option is built into its plan documents. Also describes converting after-tax money to a Roth IRA.2 |
| Form 1099-R for conversions | Prepared from the Both Hats contribution ledger | Included in the annual fee; the client must tell the provider when conversions happen1 |
| Form 5500-EZ | Prepared when filing is required. The owner reviews, signs and files | Provider describes preparation when the account reaches $250,000; the client must tell the provider when that happens1. The IRS filing test also covers final years and combined plan assets. |
| Where plan assets are held | Fidelity (Investment-Only account) or Schwab (Company Retirement Account); the owner is trustee | A bank account of the owner’s choosing with checkbook control, or a brokerage account at Fidelity or Schwab1 |
| Real estate, notes and other alternative investments | Not offered; plan assets are held in brokerage accounts | Yes; pricing page lists “real estate, notes, tax liens, private investments”1 |
| Participant loans | Not yet published | Loan origination included in the annual fee1 |
| Contribution-room tracking | Ledger of deferrals, employer, after-tax and conversion amounts, with receipt dates and limitation-year assignment | Publishes an annual contribution form for client records. Automated remaining-room tracking is unconfirmed.3 |
| Phone support | Not yet published | Monday–Friday, 8:00–4:00 Pacific; no extra charge1 |
Sources: 1 My Solo 401k Financial, solo 401(k) pricing page, checked 2026-11-20 and 2026-11-22. 2 My Solo 401k Financial, mega backdoor Roth page, checked 2026-11-22. 3 My Solo 401k Financial, how clients document contributions. Both Hats: pricing, as announced 2026-11-22.
Where is My Solo 401k Financial strong?
A fair comparison has to say where the other provider has the edge:
- It is available today. Both Hats is not taking enrollments yet.
- Track record. It says it has operated since 2009. Both Hats is a new company in formation.
- Investment flexibility. Its plans can hold real estate, private investments and other alternative assets, and can use a bank account with checkbook control. Both Hats supports only brokerage accounts at Fidelity and Schwab.
- Coverage of both spouses or partners under one fee, per its pricing page.
- Loans. Participant loan origination is part of the annual fee.
- Phone support during published business hours.
Where is Both Hats different?
- Price. First year: $349 vs. $650. After year one: $99 vs. $125 per year.
- The ledger does the tracking. The owner records each contribution and conversion in the planned ledger. Both Hats uses each contribution’s type, amount and receipt date to figure remaining room against the after-tax contribution deadline and the annual-additions limit. Conversion 1099-Rs and the 5500-EZ are prepared from the records the owner supplies.
- Brokerage-only by design. Both Hats plans to support brokerage investments only.
Which kind of owner is each one built for?
My Solo 401k Financial lists alternative investments, checkbook control and loans. Both Hats has not published loan terms. Owners who invest through a brokerage account and want after-tax contributions, conversions and filings tracked for them are who Both Hats is designed for. Either way, run your numbers first in the contribution-room calculator. See Both Hats pricing for the current terms.
This page compares services, not investments. It is educational information, not tax, legal or investment advice.