Solo 401(k) vs. SEP IRA for a sole proprietor in 2027

Last reviewed by a credentialed actuary on our team

Short answer

In 2027, a sole proprietor with no employees and unused employee deferral room can generally contribute more at modest profits to a solo 401(k) than to a new SEP IRA. Both accept employer contributions and can offer a Roth option. Only a suitably written solo 401(k) supports voluntary after-tax employee contributions followed by an in-plan Roth conversion.

How much can the same business contribute?

Take a graphic designer who reports business profit on Schedule C. Under a new simplified employee pension (SEP), the business contributes to an IRA for the designer. Under a solo 401(k), the designer can also elect an employee deferral from earned income. Both arrangements have an annual dollar ceiling. The employee election explains why the same profit can produce different contribution amounts well before either arrangement reaches that ceiling.12

Worked example: One owner, four possible Schedule C profits

Assume a calendar-year sole proprietor, age 40, with no employees, W-2 wages, other plans or contributions. Compare a traditional SEP employer contribution with pre-tax employee deferrals plus deductible employer contributions under a solo 401(k). The plans allow the maximum employer rate. The owner has enough cash to fund either amount. Results below are rounded to the nearest dollar after calculating in cents.34

2027 Schedule C net profit Profit less deductible half of SE tax SEP employer contribution Solo 401(k) employee + employer total
$50,000 $46,468 $9,294 $34,794
$100,000 $92,935 $18,587 $44,087
$180,000 $167,283 $33,457 $58,957
$450,000 $432,052 $75,000 $75,000

Follow the $100,000 row. Multiply profit by the Schedule SE factor of 92.35% to get $92,350 subject to self-employment tax. Here it all falls below the Social Security wage base. The Social Security rate of 12.4% and Medicare rate of 2.9% produce $14,129.55 of SE tax. The deductible half is about $7,065, leaving about $92,935 of adjusted profit. The reduced employer rate for this example is 20%, producing an employer contribution of $18,587 to the nearest dollar. Adding the unused employee deferral of $25,500 brings the solo total to $44,087 rounded.53

At $450,000 of profit, only earnings up to $192,300 are subject to the Social Security portion in this example. The Medicare portion continues above that base. Even the employer-only calculation reaches the annual dollar ceiling, so an employee deferral can change the mix inside the solo plan without increasing the total shown. The last row uses the same annual ceiling for both columns.54

Why starting from gross receipts gives the wrong number

The worksheet begins with net profit after business expenses. It then accounts for the deductible portion of self-employment tax and the owner’s own contribution. A plan rate stated as a percentage of compensation creates a circular calculation for a self-employed owner because the contribution itself reduces the compensation base. Publication 560 supplies a reduced rate and a deduction worksheet to handle that calculation. A business owner’s cash draws, gross invoices and bank balance do not supply that figure.3

The example uses full regular deferrals at profit levels that support them. At very low profit, earned income can limit the deferral, and the worksheet can reduce the employer amount when the owner also defers. A participant with unused catch-up eligibility may have more solo room than shown. Someone who already used the regular deferral at an unrelated day job has less. The personal deferral limit follows the individual across those 401(k) plans, while the side business can still have room for its own employer contribution. Related employers and certain 403(b) arrangements need a separate aggregation analysis.26

What counts as Roth under each arrangement?

In a solo 401(k) that offers designated Roth deferrals, the participant can elect current taxation on some or all of the employee deferral. Pre-tax and Roth deferrals share the same regular limit. SECURE 2.0 also allows a plan to offer Roth treatment for fully vested employer matching or nonelective contributions. The participant must elect the designation by the time the contribution is allocated. The amount enters gross income in the year of allocation. The employer contribution still uses employer and annual-additions room.7

SECURE 2.0 also permits Roth SEP IRAs. If the employer offers the option and the participant elects it before the contribution, the employer can contribute to the participant’s Roth SEP IRA. An employer contribution there is included in the participant’s income for the year it is made to the IRA. A SEP provider’s ability to accept and report that contribution matters when comparing actual accounts. An owner can make the Roth election only under an arrangement that supports it.7

Voluntary after-tax employee contributions are a third category. A solo plan with that provision can accept them within its remaining compensation and annual-additions limits. If the same plan permits in-plan Roth rollovers, the participant can convert eligible money to the designated Roth account. Earnings included in the conversion can produce taxable income even though the original after-tax principal was taxed already. This is the in-plan version of the mega backdoor Roth. A newly established SEP offers employer contributions and has no corresponding employee contribution source or in-plan conversion. Ordinary personal IRA contributions, where allowed, follow the separate IRA rules.81

How does a traditional SEP affect a backdoor Roth IRA?

A backdoor Roth IRA usually involves making a nondeductible traditional IRA contribution and converting money to a Roth IRA. Form 8606 calculates the tax-free share using the individual’s total basis in traditional IRAs and the relevant balances and distributions across those IRAs. Its year-end valuation includes the person’s traditional SEP and traditional SIMPLE IRAs, including accounts at other institutions. Qualified plan assets still held in a solo 401(k) fall outside that IRA calculation. A Roth SEP IRA also sits outside the traditional IRA balance.9

For example, an owner has $4,000 of nondeductible IRA basis and converts the full $4,000 from that account. A separate traditional SEP IRA still holds $36,000 at year end. Assume no other traditional IRAs, rollovers, gains or distributions. The fraction is $4,000 ÷ ($36,000 + $4,000), or one tenth. That makes $400 of the conversion tax-free and $3,600 taxable. The unused $3,600 of basis carries forward. If the $36,000 had instead remained entirely in a solo 401(k), the same assumptions give $4,000 ÷ $4,000, so the entire IRA conversion would recover basis. The location of the existing savings explains the difference.9

Which dates and filings belong on the calendar?

SEP adoption and funding. A proprietor can generally set up a SEP for the tax year and fund the employer contribution by the business return deadline, including a valid extension. The employer keeps a written agreement, provides the required information to eligible workers and arranges an IRA for each participant. A standard SEP generally has no employer Form 5500 annual return. The IRA custodian’s account reporting and the owner’s income tax reporting still matter, particularly where the owner elects Roth treatment.17

Solo 401(k) adoption, election and funding. Employer contributions generally have the following funding deadline for a prior-year deduction. The business's tax-return due date, including extensions. The Code also permits retroactive adoption for employer contributions under specified conditions. In an established calendar-year sole proprietor plan, the owner generally makes the employee deferral election by year end and can fund the elected amount by the business return deadline, including extensions. The IRS describes a narrower first-year exception for an individual who owns the entire unincorporated business and is its only employee. That owner can adopt a new plan after year end and make a first-year deferral by the individual’s original return due date, excluding extensions. Hiring an employee or moving to a later plan year changes the analysis.103

A voluntary after-tax employee contribution has a separate receipt rule for credit to the prior limitation year. For calendar 2027 the regulatory receipt window ends on . Both Hats uses as its operational receipt target. The date of an eventual conversion can fall in a different tax year from the contribution it converts.118

Solo 401(k) annual return. The owner maintains the plan document, elections and records by participant and source. For a continuing one-participant plan, Form 5500-EZ is generally required when combined year-end assets of the employer’s one-participant plans exceed $250,000. The final plan year requires a return even below the threshold. Someone comparing plans at startup may see little difference in annual filing at first, then encounter a filing obligation after a rollover or years of investment gains.12

Which business circumstances change the comparison?

A business seeking only an employer contribution can use a SEP even if the owner waits until tax-return preparation to settle on an amount. In a business with eligible employees, a SEP generally requires the same contribution percentage for eligible participants under its allocation formula. A business that hires workers also needs to reassess solo 401(k) eligibility and the coverage and testing rules once employees qualify.12

For an owner with unused deferrals, the gap between the SEP and solo totals shows how much the employee election adds at each profit level. For an owner who wants Roth treatment, the next question is whether the dollars come from an employer deposit, a regular employee deferral or a voluntary after-tax contribution followed by conversion. Those choices call for different plan provisions and records. The calculator models supported solo 401(k) scenarios using the 2027 contribution limits. The planned cost and scope of Both Hats’ document and filing preparation are on the pricing page.

Footnotes

  1. IRS, SEP frequently asked questions and Publication 560, chapter 2, employer contributions, participant coverage, setup and annual filing. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4

  2. IRS, One-participant 401(k) plans, employee and employer roles, shared deferral limit and hiring employees. ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  3. IRS, Publication 560, chapters 4 and 5, contribution timing, Rate Worksheet and Deduction Worksheet for Self-Employed. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4

  4. IRS, Notice 2026-66, 2027 limits under §§402(g), 415(c) and 401(a)(17). ↩ ↩2

  5. IRS, Instructions for Schedule SE, net earnings and deductible portion. Social Security Administration, 2027 COLA fact sheet, taxable wage base. ↩ ↩2

  6. IRS, Publication 571, chapter 3, combining contributions to plans of a controlled business and a 403(b). ↩

  7. IRS, Notice 2024-2, section K for Roth SEPs and section L for designated Roth matching and nonelective contributions. ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  8. IRS, Designated Roth accounts and in-plan Roth rollovers, eligible balances and taxable amount. ↩ ↩2

  9. IRS, Form 8606, Part I and Instructions for Form 8606, definitions and computation of the nontaxable portion. ↩ ↩2

  10. IRS, Deductibility of employer contributions made after year end, §401(b)(2), §404(a)(6) and first-year deferrals. ↩

  11. Treasury, 26 CFR §1.415(c)-1(b)(6)(i)(C), crediting voluntary employee contributions. ↩

  12. IRS, Instructions for Form 5500-EZ, small-plan exception and final return. ↩

Educational information only, not tax, legal or investment advice. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it.